Are Payroll Taxes a Debit or Credit?

Debit

Employer payroll taxes are a debit. The employer share of Social Security, Medicare and unemployment tax is an expense, so it increases with a debit. The employee share withheld from wages is not an expense at all; it is part of gross wages and sits in a liability until it is remitted.

Account category: Expense
Normal balance: Debit (Dr)
Increases with: Increase (Dr)
Decreases with: Decrease (Cr)
Financial statement: Income statement

Payroll taxes
Debit (Dr)	Credit (Cr)
Increase (Dr)	Decrease (Cr)
Employer share11,900.00	Closed at year end11,900.00

The side that increases payroll taxes is shaded.

Classifying one account is easy. Ledger IQ classifies the whole trial balance.

Try it free

Payroll taxes on a trial balance

A working trial balance extract. Totals tie, and the row this page is about is highlighted.
Acct #	Account	Debit	Credit
1000	Cash	48,200.00
1200	Accounts receivable	86,400.00
1300	Inventory	72,500.00
1500	Equipment, net of depreciation	82,000.00
2000	Accounts payable		31,500.00
2400	Notes payable		85,000.00
3900	Equity, beginning of year		172,600.00
4000	Sales revenue		550,000.00
4100	Sales returns and allowances	12,000.00
4200	Interest income		1,200.00
5000	Cost of goods sold	240,000.00
6000	Salaries and wages	96,000.00
6050	Officer compensation	60,000.00
6060	Payroll taxes (the account this page is about)	11,900.00
6100	Rent expense	36,000.00
6150	Insurance expense	14,400.00
6200	Utilities expense	9,600.00
6250	Advertising expense	7,200.00
6275	Meals	4,800.00
6300	Depreciation expense	19,000.00
6350	Amortization expense	4,000.00
6400	Bad debt expense	3,500.00
6450	Interest expense	6,800.00
6900	Other operating expenses	26,000.00
	Total	840,300.00	840,300.00

A working trial balance extract. Totals tie, and the row this page is about is highlighted.

Example journal entries

Recording the employer share on a $40,000 payroll
Account	Debit	Credit
Payroll taxes	3,060.00
Payroll liabilities		3,060.00

7.65% for Social Security and Medicare, plus unemployment tax. Employer money, so employer expense.

Depositing $12,860 of withholding and employer tax together
Account	Debit	Credit
Payroll liabilities	12,860.00
Cash		12,860.00

One payment, and none of it is an expense. The expense was recorded with the payroll.

Why it works that way

The employer half of payroll tax is a genuine cost of employing people, so it is an expense and it is a debit. The employee half is not a cost to the employer at all. It is money the business withheld from wages it already deducted, so recording it as a second expense deducts the same dollars twice.

That distinction is the whole account. The deposit that goes to the IRS contains both halves, which is why clients who record the deposit as the expense end up overstating the deduction.

What the deposit actually contains

A single payroll tax deposit typically includes federal income tax withheld from employees, the employee share of Social Security and Medicare, and the employer share of Social Security and Medicare. Only the last of those is an employer expense.

So the deposit is not an expense entry. It is a debit to the payroll liability that was set up when the payroll was recorded.

Where it goes on the return, and what else lands there

Payroll taxes go in taxes and licenses, with other deductible taxes: state unemployment, franchise taxes in most states, property taxes, business licenses.

What does not belong there:

Federal income tax on a C corporation, which is not deductible and belongs in income taxes payable and its own expense account
Sales tax collected from customers, which is a liability rather than an expense
Penalties, which are never deductible
The employee share of payroll tax, which is part of wages

A taxes and licenses account that is close to a round number, or that moves in a way payroll does not explain, is usually carrying one of those.

The check that catches the common error

Employer payroll tax expense should be roughly 7.65% of wages up to the Social Security wage base, plus Medicare on everything above it, plus unemployment tax, which is small and capped per employee.

If the account is close to 15% of payroll, both halves are in there, and the deduction is overstated by about half the balance.

Where it fits in the accounting equation

Assets

Liabilities

Equity

Expense sits on the equity side of the equation.

Tax return treatment

Where this account is reported on each business return
Form	Line
Form 1120	Page 1 line 17, taxes and licenses
Form 1120S	Page 1 line 12, taxes and licenses
Form 1065	Page 1 line 14, taxes and licenses

Common questions

Are payroll taxes a debit or credit?

The employer share is a debit, because it is an expense. The employee share withheld from wages is neither an expense nor a debit to an expense account; it is part of gross wages and sits in a liability until remitted.

Is the employee portion of Social Security an employer expense?

No. It comes out of wages the employer has already deducted. Recording it as a separate expense deducts the same money twice, which usually shows up as a payroll tax account close to 15% of wages rather than around 7.65% plus unemployment.

Is the payroll tax deposit an expense?

No. The expense is recorded when the payroll is recorded. The deposit clears the liability. Coding deposits straight to expense is what leaves an old balance sitting in payroll liabilities that never moves.

Where do payroll taxes go on the tax return?

In taxes and licenses: line 17 of Form 1120, line 12 of Form 1120S, line 14 of Form 1065. Federal income tax on a C corporation does not belong there, and neither do penalties or sales tax collected from customers.